Heritage Suspension: Law on Public Emergencies
Document Type
Book Chapter
Journal Title
The Routledge Handbook of Heritage and the Law
Publication Date
2-14-2024
Abstract
Cultural Heritage remains under threat from a vast array of public emergencies including armed conflicts, natural disasters (and related environmental threats), and a variety of direct human threats, such as social unrest. The law designed to mitigate these threats likewise varies depending on several factors. These governing factors include whether the property is movable or immovable (or even intangible), whether the property is public or private (in character or based on control), and whether the status of the property or the circumstances falls within the scope of an international treaty or instead falls within the presumed mandate of state or local authorities. Most law concerning heritage in public emergencies aims, not surprisingly, at the preservation of heritage to a time beyond the emergency. The clearest such rules operate against direct attacks on tangible heritage, both movable and immovable, by human actors. In the international arena, the law of armed conflict (also referred to as international humanitarian law) has barred the deliberate destruction, vandalism, and seizure of tangible heritage for more than a century, fully backed by more recent criminal codes to redress violations. At the domestic level, intentional attacks on and thefts of heritage typically violate domestic criminal codes, which sometimes subject violators to heightened penalties compared to those who commit attacks on property more generally. This chapter maintains that the law applicable to heritage in public emergencies often becomes less clear, less robust, and less comprehensive as one moves away from direct attacks on tangible heritage. In the face of many public emergencies, the inchoate regimes and isolated strands therefore can increase burdens on heritage professionals to fill the gaps. Specifically, heritage professionals must sometimes anticipate and respond to exigencies themselves, acting from principles of stewardship rather than legal obligation. At the same time, trends in heritage protection show that the gaps are closing. First, public emergencies often prompt the novel application of unexpected legal tools to heritage protection, such as the use of law-enforcement tools traditionally directed at curbing drug trafficking or organized crime to combat an emergency-related spike in trafficked heritage. Second, several legal regimes are expanding rapidly toward requiring prophylactic measures for heritage protection, with heritage professionals sometimes playing a central part. The obligation of governments to prepare valuable heritage to withstand the risks of armed conflict represents just one example. Finally, shared concern for endangered heritage – which often generates heightened concern during public emergencies compared to everyday threats, such as gradual degradation – has accelerated a movement toward shared responsibilities in heritage protection among various stakeholders.
Recommended Citation
Carstens, Anne-Marie and Byrne, J. Peter, "Heritage Suspension: Law on Public Emergencies" (2024). Book Chapters. 24.
https://scholarworks.law.ubalt.edu/fac_bookchapters/24