Document Type
Article
Journal Title
University of Colorado Law Review
Volume
97
First Page
1111
Publication Date
2026
Abstract
In recent decades, the continuing wartime destruction of cultural sites and artifacts alongside mass atrocities—and a rising tide of atrocities‑centered allegations in international tribunals—have spurred calls to revive a maximalist definition of genocide. The original definition of “genocide” and early drafts of the treaty on genocide identified not only physical and biological methods of destroying a group, but also “cultural” methods whereby a targeted group’s cultural sites were demolished, its cultural objects repurposed, and its cultural activities curtailed.This maximalist, three‑pronged approach sought to account for the “sinister panorama” of methods used to eliminate all aspects of a targeted population. Treaties, tribunals, and customary law to date, however, have entrenched a minimalist meaning that sharply restricts the crime of genocide to physical killing and specific biological harms. Largely for this reason, critics dismiss calls to return cultural genocide to the fold of the crime of “genocide” as unlikely.
This Article delivers a different, more provocative, retort: that redefining or interpreting “genocide” to encompass attacks on cultural heritage as a standalone version of the crime is not only unlikely, but unnecessary. The concept of cultural genocide has obtained functional force through other developments in the international legal landscape. A myopic fixation on reintroducing cultural genocide to “genocide” disregards the better capacity of legal surrogates to confront animus‑based cultural heritage destruction and misappropriation, especially given intractable challenges in proving genocide. The Article relies on several developments to confirm that legal surrogates fill much of the void between the maximalist and minimalist approaches to genocide, at least with respect to cultural heritage. In particular, intervening developments in international humanitarian law, international criminal law, and international human rights law mutually reinforce the concept of cultural genocide to establish a surrogate regime. Recent developments include prosecutions in the International Criminal Court for damage to the UNESCO World Heritage site at Timbuktu, as well as rulings in the International Court of Justice on a key human rights treaty on eliminating racial discrimination. The Article further maintains that although this existing surrogate regime may not provoke the same degree of moral opprobrium aroused by the freighted term “genocide,” the regime cumulatively shows more promise for future development and even likely exceeds the results that would be obtained by formalizing “cultural genocide” within the definition or legal construct of “genocide.”
Recommended Citation
Carstens, Anne-Marie, "Cultural Genocide’s Surrogates" (2026). Articles. 71.
https://scholarworks.law.ubalt.edu/fac_articles/71